The actor received recognition in two lead acting categories, one for his work in Netflix’s psychological thriller “The Beast in Me” and another for Apple TV+’s horror comedy “Widow’s Bay,” placing him in rare company in Emmy history.
Matthew Rhys Earns Two Lead Emmy Nominations in the Same Year
Rhys was nominated for Outstanding Lead Actor in a Limited or Anthology Series or Movie for “The Beast in Me,” where he plays Nile Jarvis, a wealthy real estate executive whose past becomes the focus of a grieving novelist investigating the disappearance of his first wife. The Netflix limited hit stars Claire Danes opposite Rhys and blends psychological suspense with crime drama, earning praise during its release in late 2025.
Source: Amy Sussman/Getty Images
His second nomination came in the Outstanding Lead Actor in a Comedy Series category for “Widow’s Bay.” The Apple TV+ title casts Rhys as Tom Loftis, the skeptical mayor of a small New England island plagued by a centuries-old supernatural curse. Mixing horror, mystery, and comedy, the show became one of the breakout television successes of 2026, collecting 19 Emmy nominations, including Outstanding Comedy Series.
The achievement makes Rhys the first male actor this century to receive lead acting nominations in two of the Emmys’ three major program categories during the same year. While multiple performers have earned two acting nominations in a single ceremony, it is considerably rarer for both recognitions to come in lead categories.
The previous male actor to accomplish the feat was John Goodman in 1995. He was nominated for Outstanding Lead Actor in a Miniseries or a Special for “Kingfish: A Story of Huey P. Long” while also competing for Outstanding Lead Actor in a Comedy Series for “Roseanne.” Neither performance ultimately won, with the awards going to Raul Julia for “The Burning Season” and Kelsey Grammer for “Frasier.”
For Rhys, the dual nominations highlight the breadth of his recent television work. In the span of a single Emmy season, he earned recognition for leading performances in two dramatically different genres, one built around psychological crime and the other combining supernatural horror with comedy, a combination that has rarely been recognized at the highest level of television awards.
