This year, ditch the standard fare and dive into the deep cuts. Our list of 25 Underrated Christmas Movies digs past the blockbusters to unearth the hidden gems, cult classics, and off-kilter holiday favorites that deserve a spot in your annual rotation. From darkly comedic masterpieces to genuinely moving indie dramas, these films offer unique twists on festive cheer, proving that the best seasonal magic is often found where you least expect it. Get ready to discover your new favorite Christmas tradition.
Arthur Christmas (2011)
Arthur Christmas offers a fresh and imaginative take on Santa’s global operation, blending heartfelt storytelling with clever humor. The film follows Arthur, Santa’s well-intentioned son, as he embarks on a mission to deliver a misplaced present before Christmas morning. Its warm message, inventive animation, and overlooked charm make it a standout holiday film that deserves more attention.
Spirited (2022)
Spirited offers a modern musical twist on A Christmas Carol, pairing Ryan Reynolds and Will Ferrell in a lively, self-aware retelling of the classic story. With energetic choreography, original songs, and sharp humor, the film revitalizes the familiar narrative for a new generation. Although it premiered on streaming platforms, it remains underappreciated compared to traditional theatrical holiday releases.
Krampus (2015)
Blending horror and dark comedy, Krampus explores the folklore of the horned Christmas figure who punishes misbehaving families. The film’s practical effects, eerie atmosphere, and unexpected emotional depth set it apart from typical holiday fare. Despite gaining a cult following, it still flies under the radar for viewers seeking something different during the season.
12 Dates of Christmas (2011)
This ABC Family original follows a woman stuck reliving Christmas Eve repeatedly, forcing her to confront her choices and open her heart. Combining romance with a time-loop structure, the film provides a charming, lightweight holiday watch. While lesser known, its sweet message and relatable characters make it a pleasant seasonal discovery.
Holidate (2020)
Holidate centers on two strangers who agree to be each other’s plus-one for every holiday throughout the year, eventually navigating the chaos of Christmas together. The film blends contemporary humor with familiar romantic-comedy themes, offering an easy, cheerful watch. Though popular on streaming, it remains underrated as a holiday film with surprising heart.
I’ll Be Home for Christmas (1998)
Starring Jonathan Taylor Thomas, I’ll Be Home for Christmas follows a college student racing home in time for the holiday, facing mishaps and revelations along the way. The film captures the spirit of late-’90s family comedies with its mix of humor and sentiment. Despite not achieving major box-office success, it has grown into a nostalgic seasonal favorite.
Beauty and the Beast: The Enchanted Christmas (1997)
This animated midquel places Belle and the Beast’s story during the holiday season, offering a musical tale about hope, redemption, and celebration. With new songs and returning voice actors, the film expands the world of the original Beauty and the Beast. Though often overshadowed by the main feature, it remains a charming Christmas addition for Disney fans.
The Night Before (2015)
Blending outrageous comedy with genuine emotional beats, The Night Before follows three lifelong friends determined to uphold their annual Christmas Eve tradition. The film balances raunchy humor with themes of growing up, loyalty, and the value of ritual. While it didn’t reach blockbuster status, its unique tone and strong performances have earned it a dedicated seasonal following.
Last Holiday (2006)
In Last Holiday, Queen Latifah stars as a woman who, after receiving life-altering news, decides to spend the holidays embracing every opportunity she once hesitated to pursue. The film combines optimism, gentle humor, and a touching message about living boldly. Its snowy European setting and uplifting storyline make it an often-overlooked addition to Christmas watchlists.
The Family Stone (2005)
The Family Stone explores the emotional complexities of a holiday gathering when a tightly knit family reunites for Christmas. The film’s blend of drama, romance, and understated comedy offers a nuanced portrayal of relationships and seasonal tension. Although it didn’t initially receive widespread acclaim, it has gradually become appreciated for its ensemble cast and authentic holiday atmosphere.
Christmas with the Kranks (2004)
Adapted from John Grisham’s novel Skipping Christmas, Christmas with the Kranks follows a couple attempting to forgo holiday celebrations—until unexpected circumstances force them to embrace the festivities after all. The film delivers sharp observations about community expectations and seasonal chaos, wrapped in a comedic narrative. Over time, its relatable storyline has earned it a more favorable place in holiday viewing rotations.
Good Luck Charlie: It’s Christmas! (2011)
Based on the popular Disney Channel series, Good Luck Charlie: It’s Christmas! follows the Duncan family on a chaotic holiday trip that goes hilariously off course. While aimed at younger audiences, its relatable family dynamics and lighthearted humor give it broader appeal. Often overlooked in the sea of holiday content, it’s a warm, cheerful film that captures the spirit of togetherness.
Klaus (2019)
Klaus reimagines the origins of Santa Claus through a beautifully animated tale about a postman who brings unexpected joy to a remote, divided town. Praised for its innovative art style and emotional depth, the film earned an Academy Award nomination and critical acclaim. Despite this recognition, it remains surprisingly underwatched compared to mainstream Christmas staples, making it a modern gem worth discovering.
Trading Places (1983)
Set during the holiday season, Trading Places blends sharp social satire with classic comedy as two men from opposite backgrounds unknowingly become part of a wealthy brothers’ experiment. The film features standout performances from Eddie Murphy and Dan Aykroyd while using Christmas as a backdrop for its clever storyline. Although widely respected, it’s often left out of typical holiday rotations despite being a winter-set classic.
Die Hard (1988)
While endlessly debated as a Christmas movie, Die Hard undeniably takes place during a holiday office party and delivers seasonal elements amid the action. The film’s suspense, memorable one-liners, and unconventional use of Christmas music offer a unique alternative to traditional festive films. Though not marketed as a holiday movie, it has become a beloved—and underrated—December staple for many viewers.
The Ref (1994)
The Ref follows a burglar who takes a dysfunctional family hostage on Christmas Eve, only to find himself caught in the middle of their relentless bickering. The dark comedy delivers sharp dialogue and a humorous twist on holiday stress, making it an unconventional seasonal pick. Despite strong performances and an original premise, it remains lesser known compared to other Christmas comedies.